The
Bookshelf
Members are encouraged to submit reviews on publications
pertaining to the Indian Wars of North America. Reviews will be
published on website for the enjoyment of Hereditary Companions
and visitors. Furthermore, members are encouraged to respond to
the reviews listed.
Each review may be accessed by clicking on the title of each
respective article.
Analysis of
Dade's
Last Command!
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Laumer, Frank, Dade's Last Command! Florida:
University Press of Florida, 1995, (This publication may be
obtained from the Dade Battlefield Society, Inc., 35247 Reynolds
Road, Dade City, Florida 33523; 352-583-2974 or 352-793-4781.
Please access the
official
website for
more information.)
This is the definitive study of the march and
annihilation of Brevet Major Francis Langhorne Dade’s column
of 108
United States regulars on
28 December 1835 - an act precipitating the Second Seminole
War, 1835-1842. The author has conducted extensive and
exhaustive research on the soldiers in this command, the
Seminoles, and the terrain of the battle and massacre. He has
personally hiked the entire march in period uniform as a
re-enactor.
This detailed, vivid, historically accurate account of this
United States
military defeat rivets the attention of the reader. Major
Dade and his command were composed
prin- |
|
cipally of artillerymen and one six-pounder cannon with with
train. They wereen route from
Fort
Brooke, Tampa
Bay
to Fort King (today Ocala, Florida) - a distance of about 100
miles in order to re-enforce the troops therein. An outbreak
of hostilities was foreseen. It was hoped that war could be
averted by a demonstration of force. Ruefully, a force of a
hundred artillerymen armed with only one six-pounder and
infantry muskets was too little, too late. It should be
mentioned that these men were well trained as artillerymen;
they were essentially inadequately trained in infantry tactics
and the use of the musket! The Seminoles under Chief Micanopy
overwhelmingly outnumbered the troops, knew the terrain, and
in fact had superior fire power via their rifles -
accurate at a range of 100 yards, a distance that the
notoriously inaccurate muskets could not even reach with any
ability of inflicting damage. The Seminole ambush was well
placed killing Major Dade and almost one-half of his command
with the opening shots. The ambush, attack, and ultimate
massacre of Dade’s column was coordinated with the warrior
Osceola who personally killed Seminole Indian Agent, Wiley
Thompson, at
Fort
King on this same day. |
This work is strongly recommended by your
reviewer. The research is impeccable. The detail of action is
noteworthy. There will never be a finer book on this topic.
back to top
Indian War Sites
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Rajtar, Steve, Indian War Sites, A
Guidebook to Battlefields, Monuments, and Memorials - State By
State with
Canada and Mexico North Carolina:
McFarland & Company, Inc., 1999
The sites of both major and minor conflicts between Indians and
our pioneer progenitors have been often difficult for researchers
and history enthusiasts to locate. Information on these battles is
frequently vague and unclear. This reference work to the
battlefields, monuments and memorials provides most needed
information on the sites of these conflicts form the colonial
period to the Indian Wars' conclusions in the 1890s. A
chronological listing of battles and indexes to battle locations
are made available. Each entry concludes with a list of sources
which are keyed by serial number to the published works in the
bibliography. This is a truly bodacious undertaking and long
needed. Mr. Rajtar is to be commended.
Withal, there are some
bothersome defects. It would appear to this reviewer that the
author did not actually visit each site or his prose detail would
have been more specific in many instances. Many entries in fact
present the directions to the sites that one wishes. Ruefully,
others are at best vague. For example, this reviewer has visited
the Alabama State Historical Site of the Fort Mims Massacre of
1813 wherein almost 400 men, women and children were killed by
Creeks. This massacre precipitated the Creek War. This is an
Alabama
state park/site. The directions are available. However, it is a
difficult remote rural site to find but clearly marked when you do
find it. The author woefully does not tell us how to get there.
This pattern is repeated elsewhere. He has assumed a challenge but
does not always rise to meet it. Some states are assiduously
detailed and researched; others are adumbrated at best. The
quality of his research presentation is inconstant. He details
many small unit conflicts (this is good) but the misses
innumerable ones that all of us would be acquainted with via our
own familial stories and traditions. Further, the very topic of
this work lends itself to the copious use of cartography.
Regrettably, there are no maps presented at all.
These caveats aside, the work is of great value and should be
considered for acquisition for your Indian Wars library. To the
author's credit, he is not addicted to the politically correct. He
does not use the term "Native American" but concludes that this
reference term is nonsensical; he parses out this term and
surgically reveals its innate hypocrisy. He prefers the terms
Indians, natives, warriors, or identification by their tribal
identity. He is fair and objective to all belligerents.
back to top
Analysis of
Andrew Jackson and His Indian Wars
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Remini, Robert V.,
Andrew Jackson And His Indian Wars
New York: Viking Penguin, 2001
|
The author has previously written no less than eight books on
Andrew Jackson; he is the unquestioned scholar on
Jackson. His topic of Jackson's Indian wars is a most
controversial one in our current politically correct environment.
Nonetheless his analysis and conclusions are balanced, insightful,
and bodacious. Let us not forget that
Jackson
personally negotiated a series of treaties with the Chickasaw,
Choctaw, Seminole, Creek, and Cherokee that added immense
acreage to our United States. He personally led the military
expeditions of 1813-1814 against the Creeks in Alabama and
that of 1817-1818 against the Seminoles and Creeks in Florida
- both to unheralded success. Further, he set in motion the
pieces for the Cherokee removal of 1838-1839. His first and
foremost priority was that of U.S. national security;
he was duly con- |
cerned
with the Spanish, French, and British imperial ambitions in
our South and Southwest and how these ambitions came into play
utilizing the Indians as their pawns on the international
chessboard. From these legitimate issues flowed all of his
handling of the Indian wars, negotiations, treaties, and
removals. He was neither anti-Indian not insensitive to their
continued existence. Although Jackson is currently excoriated
in some circles by the usual malcontents uttering their facile
nostrums of latter-day liberal ideology, the author in his
final peroration in this highly recommended work concludes,
"To his dying day On June 8, 1845, Andrew Jackson genuinely
believed that what he had accomplished rescued these people
[the five civilized tribes of Cherokees, Choctaws, Chickasaws,
Seminoles, and Creeks] from inevitable annihilation. And
although no one in the modern world wishes to accept or
believe it, that is exactly what he did. He saved the five
Civilized Nations from probable extinction. |
back to top
Analysis of
The Wagon Box Fight
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Keenan, Jerry, The Wagon Box Fight
Pennsylvania: Savas Publishing Company, 2000
This is the definitive history on one of those now obscure Indian
Wars’ battles that the succeeding centuries have forgotten but
were of first news importance when they occurred. The Wagon Box
Fight occurred 2 August 1867 in the
Wyoming
Territory near Fort Kearny just south of Montana pitting some 32
soldiers and civilian woodcutters against an estimated 3,000
Indians putatively under Red Cloud - odds of about 100 to 1! The
American forces lost six killed and two wounded. It is thought
that the Indian casualties ranged from a low of 180 (60 KIA and
120 WIA) to as high as 1300! We will never know inasmuch as the
Indians removed their casualties and ever after did not wish to
discuss their losses! The eight hour continuous fight from an
encircled wagon train along the Bozeman Trail included the Indian
tribes of Cheyennes under Little Wolf, Oglala Sioux under Crazy
Horse, Miniconjous under High Back-bone, and a few Sans Arcs under
Little Wolf. It is thought that Red Cloud himself was also present
but this cannot be verified.
Of interest, the Indians thought that this fight would be a repeat
of the Fetterman Massacre of 21 December 1866 where the entire
American command of 81 soldiers were killed ... also near Fort
Kearny on a woodcutting detail. However, the Wagon Box Fight of
some nine months later within a few miles of the Fetterman
Massacre included an important tactical difference. The soldiers
were no longer firing muzzle loading .58 calibre War Between the
States Springfields. They had literally just received (a few days
before) the new Springfield-Allin Model 1865 breech-loading
.50-70-450 rifles. These rifles shot center-fire primed cartridges
manufactured in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, at the Frankford
Arsenal. This increased fire power ability drastically altered the
tactical situation leaving the Indians puzzled as to why the
soldiers did not stop to muzzle reload with the laborious
traditional ramrods. They understood that they should charge
immediately subsequent to a volley while the troops were
reloading. This time when they charged they were met by near
continuous fire and they received high casualties as the result.
This small volume reads well, is meticulously researched, and
explains in detail all that we know of this fight to include the
recent archaeological excavations. In many ways the Wagon Box
Fight was the American precursor to the British Battle of Rorke’s
Drift (Zulu War of 1879)! This book deserves a high grade.
back to top
Analysis of
Crimsoned Prairie
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Marshall, S.L.A.
Crimsoned Prairie, The Indian Wars on the Great Plains
New York: Charles Scribner’s and Sons, 1972
This superb opus was
passed on to me for consideration of review by one of our Official
Board members. Kudos to Alexander Clarke Magruder, Sr.!
Authored by renowned
historian Brigadier General S. L.A. Marshall, this work is
currently out of print. It may not be easily obtained. After all,
Russell Kirk endorsed this book! But if you look around in the
“pre-owned” book stalls and find one, you will be well rewarded.
This book is a MUST READ.
General Marshall
wrote over thirty works of history about the American soldier in
combat and the art of war, including PORK CHOP HILL, BASTOGNE,
SINAI VICTORY, and NIGHT DROP. He was one of the founders of the
War Department Historical Division and a pioneer in the area of
battle field research and he became Chief Historian of the
European Theatre of Operations in World War II. His military
service began during World War I. He has written for such
reputable newspapers as the Washington Post and the Los
Angeles Times. He has a writing style with an ability of word
command in English that is powerful, glib, and opinionated. This
book is worth the read if for no other reason than his word
construction and usage. Your attention will be riveted to the
subject matter!
Marshall places the various Plains’ wars superbly within their
historical context explaining their inevitability and their
inevitability of result. His use of irony and occasional opera
bouffe is both insightful and entertaining. From the Cheyenne Wars
in the 1860s through the Sioux Wars in the 1870s to the Nez Perce
War and the final tragic denouement of the Battle of Wounded Knee,
he has your attention. He is fond of removing the sugar coatings
and explains how many of the United States Army commanders were
less than sterling in their performance. George Armstrong Custer
takes a blistering. Likewise, he does not view our opponents as
noble savages living in a state of communal euphoria with nature.
The Indians were crude, brutal, primitive, uncivilized peoples
that could from time to time be courageous and honorable. And, in
fact, on several occasions they had equity on their side. Marshall
greatly admires Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce. Withal, like the
rest of us, they too were tainted with original sin. They
ultimately lost because that was their role. Their result in
history was irrefragable. His concluding chapter on the Battle of
Wounded Knee (he makes the point that this was a battle) is a
spellbinder. This sad battle occurred because the Indians forced
the issue. They duplicitously attempted the appearance of peaceful
intent that in fact revealed malice aforethought for violence.
They were hoisted by their own petard.
Marshall, who is part Indian himself, has little truck with the
nonsensical Rousseau-istic romantic blather still so common in our
society. He is no bleeding heart. He is a realist with a
surprising approach of objective equipoise. This book is
refreshing. And, as stated earlier, a must read!
back to top
Three Cavalry Huzzahs for Jack Hale Hansel!
Three earsplitting cavalry “Huzzahs” for Compatriot Jack Hale
Hansel of Platte City, Missouri! Our new Order of Indian Wars
stand of colors is off to an auspicious beginning with our first
acquisition to our vexillological fund. Compatriot Hansel has
graciously donated a sum sufficient to cover the costs for a
replication of one of the 7th United States Cavalry swallowtail
guidons/flags used at the Battle of Little Big Horn in June of
1876.
It should be noted that the Order has received several other
contributions for our vexillological acquisitions. These will be
listed in a future edition of The Scalp Dance.
Our specially manufactured swallowtail guidon will be of then
regulation Cavalry requisites used after
1
January 1862 and continued in use until the 1880s – 2’3” on the lance by 3’5”
on the fly with a sleeve to fit on the standard issue pike which
was 1¼” in diameter. It will have a leather tab sewn into the top
of the sleeve so that a nail could be inserted through the leather
and into the pike. This red, white, and blue flag will be 100%
silk body and with gold painted stars on both sides of the canton.
The actual surviving flag from the 7th Cavalry that is being used
as our paradigm has thirty-five stars. Thirty-five stars, because
it was one of the surplus guidons left over after the War of
1861-1865. These continued in use until 1883 at which point the
Cavalry reverted to the standard red and white guidons. The Custer
Battlefield has a 7th Cavalry thirty-five star guidon presumably
carried at the battle. Our flag will have thirteen red and white
stripes and the thirty-five gold stars painted on the canton in
the then standard arrangement of two circles, twelve inner circle,
nineteen outer circle, and one star in each corner. Our flag is
being manufactured by Gideon Flags of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
back to top
Analysis of Cooper’s Leatherstocking Tales
by Barry Christopher Howard
As is often the case with fictional literature
placed in an historical context, an accurate and balanced
perspective of the people, places, events and ideals addressed in
the work is difficult to obtain. Generally skewed by the
inevitable biases and myopic worldviews of the author, fiction
enjoys (or rather suffers from) a freedom which historical
writings do not; a freedom often weakening the literature. Rarely
is this phenomenon more prevalent than in fiction dealing with
cultural minorities or underdeveloped civilizations. In this
context, the works of James Fenimore Cooper stand apart from their
contemporary counterparts. Cooper managed to accomplish what
others could not, in his efforts to accurately depict the true
character and culture of various Northeastern American Indian
tribes and individuals.
James Fenimore Cooper was born in 1789, in
Burlington, New Jersey. Son of the wealthy landowner, Judge
William Cooper, he grew up privileged, and subject to the common
perspectives of enlightened American culture. He and his wife
lived abroad from 1826 - 1833, and during that time he vigorously
defended American democracy in his writings. Upon his return to
the
United States
he was so disgusted by what he saw as the tyranny of the majority,
or even mob rule, he acquired conservative and aristocratic views
which made him unpopular as a social commentator. However, it was
his Leatherstocking Tales, which boldly reflected
the virtues and vices of two distinct cultures that eventually
secured his place among the great writers of the English language. |
|
The Leatherstocking Tales are comprised of
five books written between 1823 and 1841. The titles in the set
include (in order written, not fictional chronology) The
Pioneers, Last of the Mohicans, The
Prairie, The Pathfinder, and The
Deerslayer. Common throughout the books is the
progressive life of their primary character, Natty Bumpo. A
rugged, yet sincere frontiersman, Bumpo serves Cooper's efforts to
systematically express the weaknesses, strengths, and general
variances of late eighteenth century Colonial and Native American
culture. His undeniable honesty and frank commentary provide an
astounding look at true American Indian belief systems and
practices. Void of any political or social agendas, Cooper
eloquently crafts his books in a manner few non-fictional,
historical analyses have rivaled.
The crossing of Colonial European and native
Indian cultures, alone, is a complex issue to address. Cooper was
successful in, not only expressing the nature of the cultural
variances and interchanges, but also in crafting excellent
literature while adhering to impeccable historical accuracy. His
own life and early geographical placement provided the extensively
descriptive backdrop to his works, while his passion to accurately
depict the nature of the individuals and groups in the
Leatherstocking Tales served as the catalyst for the
remarkably balanced perspective he provides us.
One of the unique qualities evident in the
Leatherstocking Tales, and the one most relevant to an
article composed for the Order of the Indian Wars of the
United States, is the honest depiction of the American Indian.
While era literature often rides the popular, social tide of its
day, Cooper chose brutal honesty instead. For this we are most
grateful.
Unlike the often white-washed history espoused
in modern society regarding the ethos of the American Indian and
his relations with white Colonists (later Americans), Cooper
spared no detail and compromised very little, if any. His graphic
depiction of the Massacre of William Henry stands unrivaled to
this day. Although some contemporary historians have attempted to
downplay the severity of the massacre, as described in Last
of the Mohicans, even these same historians can put the
death toll no lower than 70-180. Other accounts leave the death
toll near 1,500. Regardless of the precise number of individuals
killed at William Henry, Cooper’s grisly account of the event is a
sample of his unwavering commitment to an accurate depiction of
the vices in Indian culture.
More impressive was the fact that, conversely,
Cooper had no apprehension about attributing noble and virtuous
qualities to the American Indian when applicable. Throughout the
Leatherstocking Tales, Chingachgook, Natty Bumpo’s
wise and loyal Mohican comrade, is universally depicted with
stronger character, and a higher level of integrity than most of
the Colonial characters in the books. Furthermore, Bumpos’s
numerous, insightful, philosophical commentaries addressing each
aspect of the humanity and inhumanity of the eastern American
Indian is priceless. Through Natty Bumpo, Cooper provides a
unblemished, unbiased depiction of the American Indian at his best
and worst. In an era of general animosity toward the American
Indian, coupled with an intense national adherence to policies of
manifest destiny, the fact that American society so strongly
embraced Cooper’s impartial writings is something quite
remarkable.
The thematic bond tying each of Cooper’s books
together is the interracial tension between Indian and Eurocentric
culture. That tension is the fodder which makes Bumpo’s
relationship with his Delaware friend so astounding, and which
make the activities of the ‘Mingo’ or Huron tribes so ghastly.
Cooper deals with this dichotomy bluntly, correlating variance in
Indian culture to similar moral variance in Colonial American
culture. The synergistic result of Cooper’s efforts is the
construction of a model we can surmise to be surprisingly accurate
for its time.
While Cooper was doubtlessly encumbered by
certain contemporary biases of his day, his work expresses a view
of native American Indian lives, beliefs and social interaction
which serves, to this day, as a measuring rod for other fiction
dealing with similar ethnic groups. The author recommends
Cooper’s Leatherstocking Tales without hesitation,
and hopes new readers will enjoy them as much as he has.
back to top
Analysis of
Struggle for the Gulf
Borderlands
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Owsley, Frank Lawrence, Jr., Struggle for the Gulf
Borderlands, The Creek War and the Battle of New Orleans 1812-1815
Alabama: The University of Alabama Press, 1981
For decades to come this will be the standard reference work on
this topic. Superbly researched utilizing not only the usual
American sources, but the previously untapped archives of
Spain and Great Britain. Owsley has integrated the Creek War into
the larger framework of the War of 1812 causing the reader at some
point to pronounce “Eureka”
as you begin to acquire a whole new perspective on Andrew Jackson
and the conflict with Great Britain.
This may easily be the best history on the Creek War of
1813-1814. What could have been a completely altered history of
the United States - if Andrew Jackson had not been in command, if
he would have hesitated only weeks from the crucible campaign
concluding at the Battle of Horseshoe Bend, if the British would
have landed the state-of-the-art muskets, artillery, military
advisors/trainers, and cavalry accoutrements several weeks earlier
than they did, if the Spanish had been more pro-active than they
were for the Creeks, etc. - would have prevented us from our
Manifest Destiny! I never before have read all of this with such
fervor, explanation, and detail. Owsley makes the point that too
many of our historians have belittled our accomplishments in these
two interrelated wars and downplayed their significance. Often we
have been led to believe that the War of 1812 was a “draw.” He
makes the point that it was on balance a resounding victory.
Jackson’s being in the right place at the right time for the
Battle of New Orleans would not have occurred but for his role in
the Creek War and the overwhelming victory achieved. We would not
have had the experienced and trained troops in place under his
command but for the Creek War. And, inasmuch as the British did
not recognize the validity of the
Louisiana Purchase,
if they had won the Battle of New Orleans then the Treaty of Ghent
signed in December 1814 would not have applied to any claims that
they would have asserted over New Orleans, Louisiana, and their
planned buffer states under the Creek Indians and their allies.
The frontier would have been inflamed and we would have had strong
buffer Indian states with which to contend and two mutually
supportive European powers. All of this was prevented by Andrew
Jackson and his juggernaut victory at Horseshoe Bend. The sheer
quantum of international intrigue taking place at Pensacola and
throughout the Gulf area is enlightening.
This book is highly recommended by this reviewer. You will
receive a whole new perspective on Andrew Jackson and his brave
Tennessee
and Georgia troops in the Creek War.
back to top
Analysis of The Indian
Wars of Pennyslvania
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Sipe, C. Hale, The
Indian Wars of Pennsylvania Maryland: Heritage
Books, 1929 reprinted 2000
This
comprehensive historical work is an account of the Indian events
in Pennsylvania from the time of William Penn to the French &
Indian War, Pontiac’s War, Lord Dunmore’s War, the War of
American Independence, and the Indian uprisings from 1789 to
1795. This is definitely the ne plus ultra of historical
writing in one volume on the eighteenth century Indian Wars in
Pennsylvania. The author uses exhaustive detail drawing on both
primary and secondary sources. For his place and time the
author is surprisingly objective, perhaps at times bordering on
the politically correct. He provides explications for the inter
and intra politics of the Indian tribes, cultural attitudes and
misunderstandings, and for pages describes the atrocities
conducted by all parties but principally the Indians. Women and
children were hardly spared by the scalping knife, torture, and
mutilation. For those numerous captives that were not
immediately scalped, killed or tortured, he explains their
forced adoption into the tribes or their entering into the
status of slavery and the occasional trade in white slaves to
Canada. His descriptions of actions, depredations, and wanton
murder generally include full names of the victims, ages, and
geography and often their eventual denouement. Ergo, this book
is a genealogical goldmine for those seeking their principally
Scots-Irish or Pennsylvania German ancestors. There is a caveat,
however. This superbly detailed work is marred by a most
inadequate name index for the book. Most of those frontiersman
and their family members mentioned in great detail with their
fates are not listed in the index.
Sipe
generally furnishes detailed biography on the many characters on
the colonial Pennsylvania frontier to include the various Indian
chiefs. The complex interrelationships of the Indian leaders
and the frontiersmen is fascinating.
Topics
include: Indian religious beliefs and tribal structure, the
early treaties with William Penn, the numerous land disputes,
the several expeditions to Western Pennsylvania, George
Washington’s personal role in both the colonial and
revolutionary wars, an excellent detail of the French & Indian
War in this part of the world, General Braddock’s Defeat, the
successful General Forbes’ expedition and the fall of Ft.
Duquesne, Pontiac’s War and the Battle of Bushy Run, various
incidents of Lord Dunmore’s War and the Battle of Point
Pleasant, the scorched earth Indian warfare during the American
Revolution with great emphasis on General Sullivan’s campaign,
and eventually describing the post-revolutionary war campaigns
concluding with the Battle of Fallen Timbers. Of great scholarly
and genealogical interest are the appendices which include a
chronological table of incidents from 1570 to 1843, lists of the
monuments erected in honor of the sesqui-centennial celebration
of General Sullivan’s expedition against the Iroquois with a
listing of the Indian towns destroyed in that expedition, a
listing of the officers of the Colonies of the Delaware before
Penn, and the governors of the Province of Pennsylvania from
1681 to 1799. Also listed are the names and locations of the
principle Indian towns and the names and locations of the
various Pennsylvania forts and blockhouses.
This work is of great utility for those readers seeking
exhaustive detail. It is strongly recommended.
back to top
Analysis of Indian
Wars, the Campaign for the American West
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Yenne, Bill, Indian Wars, the Campaign for the
American West Pennyslvania: Westholme
Publishing, LLC, 2006
For a one volume primer this book cannot be beat. Yenne does an
excellent job explaining what occurred over the time period
involved from the perspective of the combatants rather than
current political correctness. The Indian Wars remain the most
misunderstood campaigns ever waged by the United States Army.
There is much misinformation. Likewise we have a tendency to view
these wars as separate incidents rather than as part and parcel to
a single campaign stretching over decades. Yenne patiently
explains that the whites were initially seen as just another tribe
by the Indians albeit a potentially powerful tribe. Further, he
goes into the motivating factors for the manifest destiny of the
American pioneers that occurred; these wars fought over some five
decades across a landscape as expansive as Europe were part of a
long-term American strategy to control the West as well as
extensions of conflicts between the Indian peoples that pre-dated
contact with the whites.
The author evaluates with equipoise both the
leaders of the various military units and of the tribes. Crazy
Horse, Sitting Bull, Chief Joseph, Geronimo, George Armstrong
Custer, George Crook, and Nelson Appleton Miles all receive
apropos attention. Of particular interest to our membership is
his meticulous attention to detail in his footnotes to each and
every Medal of Honor recipient during these hot and cold
conflicts. Yenne has examined the documents supporting these
awards and details each. I found at least two of our membership’s
ancestors mentioned when they received their Medals of Honor
explaining why they received this highest and most coveted of
American decorations. This in itself is a noteworthy item that
values this work.
This book places the people and the battles
within the context of the overall history of the nineteenth
century and the Indian Wars in the West so that their place in
American history will be better understood and their names not
forgotten. Of special interest for our readers will be his
attention to the myriad small campaigns, wars, and incidents,
e.g., the Yakima War, Red River War, Red Cloud’s War, Rogue
River War, Paiute War, Modoc War, Coeur d’Alene War, etc.
Additionally, his detailed maps are of great service to
understanding the larger picture of the Indian Wars in the West.
This work shows all of the major battles and many of the minor
ones with their locations and dates on his maps. Many of the
campaigns are shown trailed out. The maps also localize all of
the Indian reservations. His appendices show the evolution of the
Oklahoma Indian Territory, the Bureau Heads during the Western
Indian War period (Heads of the Indian Affairs Office,
Commissioners of Indian Affairs), the Commanding Generals of the
U.S. Army during this period, and the Post-Civil War [sic] U.S.
Army Organizations for 1868, 1875, 1884, and 1891.
In short, I strongly recommend this brief
history. It is pithy, detailed, fair-minded, revealing, and
places all within the larger picture of American history.
back to top
Analysis of
Bourland in North Texas and Indian Territory during
the Civil War: Fort Cobb, Fort Arbuckle & the Wichita
Mountains
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Adkins-Rochette,
Patricia,
Bourland in North Texas and
Indian Territory During the Civil War: Fort Cobb, Fort
Arbuckle & the Wichita Mountains
Self-Published, 2006
This
1,014 page tome is remarkable (which really is two volumes in
one). Little-studied, little-written, and little-researched are
the Indian conflicts during the period 1861 through 1865 on the
Southern frontier - the frontier of the Confederate States of
America. When the United States military forces withdrew in the
face of the establishment of the new fledgling Southern
republic, a partial defense vacuum was created in the areas
contiguous to the Indian lands. This book deals with the
Texas-Oklahoma border area, the Red River area. Texas had to
contribute its sons not only to the struggle to maintain the
nascent Confederate army in the War for Southern Independence
but additionally to fill the need for border security with the
many Indian tribes - the areas left vacant by the retreating
United States military units. This need was filled by the Texas
State Militia to maintain and protect its frontier from Indian
depredations. And, although many of the Indian tribes quickly
established amicable relations with this new nation, others did
not. Treaties were signed inter alia with many of the
Indian tribes such as the Cherokees, Seminoles, Creeks,
Chickasaws and Choctaws. She includes the actual text of many
of these treaties not to mention the Camp Napoleon Compact of 26
May 1865. Withal many of these tribes were split asunder with
their own civil wars regarding their perspectives on the two
republics now formed; tribes contributed Indian troops to the
armies of both warring nations. There were now also the
inevitable conflicts within the border areas between all ethnic
affiliations. Additionally many Indians saw the great War
between the whites as an open invitation for mischief. There
were full scale battles, skirmishes, attacks, raids, etc.,
e.g., not only in the Northern states of Minnesota and
Colorado which are well-documented, but also in Texas which has
not been heretofore well-documented.
Our
authoress has herein not only scoured existent published records,
but has accomplished a prodigious amount of new research from
primary sources which has never before been made public (she
indicates that 70% of her study is from handwritten records). She
has made an impressive contribution to our knowledge of the local
conflicts between the Indian nations and the Confederate Texas
Militia as well as the Confederate Indian units themselves. Her
compilations of the militia posts and hideouts, details on John
Jumper’s Seminole Regiment, Stand Watie’s Cherokee Regiment, an
immense amount of biographical material on Colonel Bourland’s life
and military service, the Texas Ranging Companies, Indian
Territorial Posts, deserters, frontier personalities and
conditions from the 1840s through the 1860s, and the descriptions
of several battles such as those of Elm Creek and Village Creek,
and the many sanguinary raids (over 300,000 cattle were stolen or
levied), and a set of invaluable maps. Several hundreds of new
documents have been transcribed to include 43 letters to and from
Colonel James G. Bourland and General H.E. McCulloch - documents
not found in the Official Record that presumably should be therein- along with
a myriad of muster rolls for north Texas Militia Brigades (to be
specific, the militia listings for 34 Texas counties) and the
associated brigade correspondence. Mrs. Adkins-Rochette has
detailed the Tonkawa Massacre of 1862. Her appendices are of
great value in this her magnum opus. For those of you with
Red River area antecedents, this work will be of great interest.
This hardback
tome is self-published which means that you must purchase it
directly from the authoress at: Mrs. Patricia Adkins-Rochette,
1509 Shadybrook Lane, Duncan, OK, 73533.
The price is $125.00 plus postage. Her phone number is
580-252-2094. E-mail address is
prochette@juno.com.
She also has a website for this volume
www.BourlandCivilWar.com.
The Blue, the Gray & and
the Red;
Indian Campaigns of the Civil War
by
Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Hatch, Thom,
The Blue, the Gray
& and the Red; Indian Campaigns of the Civil War
Pennsylvania:
Stackpole Books, 2003
This may be the
first work dedicated solely to chronicling the numerous
campaigns waged against the Indians in the West during the War
Between the States, 1861-1865. Perhaps more Indians - and
possibly more Americans - were killed during this time period
than any other comparable four year period of the Indian Wars in
our history. Yet most Americans are quite ignorant of all that
transpired in these Indian campaigns no doubt due to the
overarching dominance of that most sanguinary other War. Both
Confederate and Federal soldiers had to maintain two front wars
- against each other and the Indians. In each nation manpower
drains for the main war were such that all too often the
campaigns for frontier survival were fought with untrained and
inexperienced militia. The Indians comprehended all of this and
many acted with great mischief.
Concomitantly the
War Between the States also divided the loyalties of many tribes
with organized units fighting for both the Confederacy (who had
Indian nations’ representatives in their congress with the
intention of eventually bringing them in as their own states)
and the Union. We must not lose sight of the fact that the last
commissioned general in the Confederacy to surrender was
Cherokee chief Brigadier General Stand Watie on 23 June 1865.
Although
this well written eminently readable book fills in a much needed
gap in understanding our history of the many campaigns with the
various Indian tribes during this time period, it is woefully
lacking more in its analysis and descriptions of the campaigns
in the Confederacy. There are only several paragraphs outlining
these skirmishes and battles. The title of this work certainly
suggests more than what is provided. Much has yet to be
researched and written hereon. And, we know that there were many
fights worth relating with the Indians on the “Southron”
frontier. See, e.g., Book Review of
BOURLAND IN NORTH TEXAS
AND INDIAN TERRITORY DURING THE CIVIL WAR: Fort Cobb, Fort
Arbuckle & The Wichita Mountains, by Patricia Adkins-Rochette
(2006), reviewed 9 May 2006 on <<
www.OIWUS.org
>>. For the open-minded researcher, this is a field of history
still in dire need!
Nonetheless, those
campaigns described are fascinating. The author leads us
through several of the bloody battles between partisan Indian
tribes during the War Between the States explaining the politics
of it all (this is well done - it can be most confusing) with
the consequences to each side. Even history enthusiasts for the
War are frequently uninformed with reference to the fratricidal
intra-Indian campaigns. He then goes into the several Apache
campaigns, the Great Sioux Uprising of 1862 in Minnesota wherein
scores of quite innocent newly arrived German immigrants were
massacred and worse, the Bear River Massacre, the Woolsey
Expedition, Northern and Southern Plains vengeance, and
ultimately the woeful Sand Creek Massacre.
Of note, the Sioux
War of 1862 caused the burning of much of the town of New Ulm -
190 houses, and culminated after several set battles with the
largest mass hanging under the colour of law in American history
on American soil. On 26 December 1862, after receiving approval
by Union President Abraham Lincoln, 38 Indians were publicly
hanged for their depredations in this war.
This book is
excellent. It is recommended - its noted blemishes aside - to the
serious student of the Indian Wars.
back to top
Three Cavalry Huzzahs for
Nicolas Ignacio Quintana,
Esq.!
Three earsplitting cavalry “Huzzahs” for Compatriot Nicolas
Ignacio Quintana, Esq. of Atlanta, Georgia. Mr.
Quintana made a recent
contribution to our Order in memory of his ancestor (great
grandfather), CAPT Stephen Y. Seyburn of the 10th United States
Infantry and an original companion of the Order, Badge No. 34.
Indian War Veterans, Memories of Army
Life
and Campaigns in the West 1864-1898
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Greene, Jerome A.,
Indian War Veterans, Memories of Army Life and Campaigns in
the West 1864-1898 New York:
Savas Beatie, 2007
This comprehensive
compilation of essentially enlisted men’s reminiscences is a
superb collection of actual anecdotes, recollections, and
experiences by the men who were there. Being enlisted men, their
stories are limited to their actual tactile hands-on encounters.
In a sense this is thoroughly refreshing; this is quite different
from the all to frequent recollections of those in command that
tend to justify their actions and critique their colleagues. As a
result there are few explanations as to why they were sent to do
what they did, but intense detail on what they saw and felt as
participants. This is a prime history of observations by those who
were there. Many have never before been published, or were
published in arcane publications over a century ago and for all
practical purposes have been unavailable to the serious scholar or
student. The emphasis is on the Plains campaigns but those against
the Apache and the Southwest are not ignored. A chapter on the
ill-fated Custer expedition is to be expected, but the first hand
accounts are new. The details on the Rosebud and Powder River
fights are excellent. Often overlooked campaigns and skirmishes
are also included such as those of the Modoc War of 1873, Utah’s
Black Hawk War of 1865, the Chippewa Uprising of 1898, etc.
It should be noted that
not all the recollections are those of battles. There are several
fascinating remembrances of the cuisine, climate (especially the
winters), geography, the Indians themselves and their habitat, the
buffalo, Christmas, military life as a cavalryman, and military
life as an infantryman. All in all, these writings by the men who
lived through these times are not to be missed.
Of distinct note for the
true aficionado of the Indian Wars is the lengthy introduction
which details the sundries Indian Wars veterans associations,
their histories, decorations (previously almost impossible to find
photographs of many of their medals are provided), leaders, and
their lobbying efforts before Congress for pension benefits and
recognition for their noteworthy achievements as soldiers “winning
the West.” The only criticism one can proffer at all, and it is a
minor one, is that the information furnished regarding the Order
of Indian Wars of the United States is less than currently
accurate. This sodality may have gone into partial hibernation
from the 1940s and into the 1990s, but it never actually ceased to
function; it continued to have an annual luncheon for its members.
It reinitiated full functioning in the 1990s and is alive and well
today. This reviewer strongly endorses this work to anyone
sincerely interested in the Indian Wars of the second half of the
nineteenth century and the intrepid men who fought them.
back to top
A Conquering Spirit, Fort Mims and the
Redstick War of 1813-1813
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Waselkov, Gregory
A.,
A Conquering Spirit, Fort Mims and
the Redstick War of 1813-1813
Alabama:
The University of Alabama Press, 2006
This must be lucidly the ne plus ultra
for this fascinating conflict. The research is indefatigable,
thorough, and multi-faceted. The author has utilized the skills of
historian, archaeologist, anthropologist, ethnologist, and
genealogist. It is only after his melding these elements all
together that the trees become clearly delineated from the woods.
His explication of family relationships and interactions sheds
light on otherwise difficult to understand actions by the
participants. His explanation of the clan and kinship systems used
by the Creeks and the inevitable cultural conflicts that arose
with the Americans are invaluable.
Probably few Americans grasp that the Ft. Mims Massacre of 30
August 1813 was presumably the greatest massacre of cultural
non-Indians of the many Indian Wars in our four hundred years of
history. Even fewer grasp that of the hundreds killed, many were
not white but included large numbers of cross-breeds of Indian and
white (the author interestingly refers to them as métis
which is a French derived word for "mixed" similar to the Spanish
mestizo) and blacks - not to mention that these included
numerous women and children. Ultimately the fight descended into a
massacre of civilians by the Creek Indians many of whom themselves
were métis and therefore related to those whom they were
killing. There is great academic debate on exactly how many were
killed but most historians agree that the number is between 350
and 530. It was not pretty.
This exhaustively endnoted volume details the story of this fierce
fight at the fortified plantation home of Samuel Mims in the
Tensaw District in what is today Baldwin County, Alabama, north of
Mobile. Essentially this massacre triggered the Creek War of
1813-1814 that had been incubating for some time with the many
social forces that conflated to spark the massacre and war.
Ultimately it was Andrew Jackson that terminated this sanguinary
war with his historic victory at Horseshoe Bend. The Creeks never
really recovered after this war that they initiated with the great
massacre at Samuel Mims plantation.
This magnus opus of the Ft. Mims
massacre in the Redstick War is strongly recommended. It presents
the many different perspectives of the protagonists with equity.
20 June 2008
back to top
Indian Wars of the American South
1610-1858; A Guide for Genealogists & Historians
A Review
by Hon. Richard Bender Abell
Ports, Michael A., Indian Wars of
the American South 1610-1858; A Guide for Genealogists &
Historians Baltimore: Clearfield Company, 2017.
A great deal is poured into these pages of
critical interest to both the genealogist and the historian.
This is a comprehensive research work long needed. Beginning
with the Three Powhatan Wars of 1610-1646 and concluding with
the Third Seminole War of 1855-1858, this work presents all to
the reader in a concise and understandable fashion.
The first section presents a narrative of
each of the twenty seven separate and distinct Indian wars in or
including the American South (which includes Virginia, North and
South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Florida,
Kentucky, Tennessee, Louisiana, and West Virginia). A narrative
is presented to include a discussion of the background issues,
the campaigns, and the aftermath/consequences. He presents the
names and ranks of as many of the commanding officers and
military units with battle locations and dates as the author
can. Then is presented a section with the known current
historical sites giving their addresses and photos of the sites
or campaign signs thereat today. This is invaluable for those
who intend to visit the sites. Further, he concludes each war
with a bibliography of books, articles, journals, etc., for
further study. This, too, is invaluable for both the genealogist
and the armchair historian.
For those who seek more detail the author
then gifts the reader with a detailed listing and explanation of
contents of repositories of information on the Indian Wars
starting with the Federal archives, to include military pension
records, military bounty land warrant records, and Native
American records by tribe. He gets very specific with microfilm
rolls and further bibliographies and details the assets of the
Library of Congress. At the conclusion of the section on Federal
records he initiates a detailed listing of state archives and
records. For the researcher who is a non-resident of these
locales this is more than inestimable. A section is then
provided with the various Indian records in their many
locations. He concludes with a section on other (generally
private) significant repositories and sources state by state.
All in all this is a Herculean effort of
great purpose to the genealogist and/or historical researcher.
My one critical observation, however, is that no maps are
presented. These would be of immense assistance. Withal I must
give this work a strong approval rating. I found it personally
fascinating. It placed many Indian conflicts in perspective
outlining a lucid picture of several hundred years of Southern
history.
27 August 2018
back to top
Copyright ©
The Order of Indian Wars of the United States
|